The Buckeye Lady

Holly Wornstaff a month ago

Excellent buckeyes, kind employees, clean shop. They have a fair amount of Gluten Free options as well. If you love buckeyes, this is the place for you!

Tyla Hall 2 months ago

I tried the pickle‑stuffed buckeyes this past week after seeing them featured on the 614Now website, and I enjoyed them very much. It was the perfect combination of salty, tangy, and sweet without it being too weird or overpowering. I also bought a box of the dog‑safe buckeyes for my grandfather's dog at the Common Greens Farmers Market, but unfortunately he didn't like them. I was surprised to find out that the bakery that makes them is only a 15‑minute walk from us. I'll definitely have to stop by again to try more buckeyes.

Megan Mott 2 months ago

Visited Columbus for the first time recently and was on the hunt for the best buckeyes. Reviews led me to The Buckeye Lady. Out of all the buckeyes I tasted, these were by far the best tasting. Absolutely amazing! We bought a box of six and tried six different kinds. Each one was delicious. If I could give stars for taste alone, I would give it 10 stars! The only reason I removed a star was the price. Holy moly, they were expensive! If you truly want the best tasting in the area, I would definitely go here! If you want to save a little money, you might want to try elsewhere first. There were some other shops that tasty buckeyes, but not quite as good! Added note: the person working there was absolutely lovely! So sweet and so helpful!

Janet Konicek 6 months ago

OMG moment trying these traditional Buckeys! The Best we have ever had! They are so good it's unbelievable! I would give these Buckeys 20 stars. We found these at the Worthington Farmers market.

David Trisel a year ago

On Tuesdays, I explore new places for a meal. The restaurant I chose shall remain nameless as it was a little lackluster. I left there wanting something more. So I googled nearby desserts, and the buckeye lady popped up. We had never heard of the store, but are more than familiar with the Typical chocolate and peanut butter treat. I was hoping this might salvage my day of exploring, and it did not disappoint! There were flavors I didn’t know I needed it in it, and now I do. The staff member that was assisting us, was very patient and answered more questions than she probably felt she needed to to make one sale! I cannot tell you how much everyone should have a PB and J Buckeye. Also adding cinnamon roll cream cheese frosting in the middle and a sprinkle of cinnamon is pure genius. Salted caramel with a crisp pretzel is also a solid choice. But my absolute favorite out of the pack was the coconut and almond. Do not sleep on that one. I don’t know if it’s a seasonal flavor or if that’s something they have all the time. But get you one! I wish I could give more stars than just five.